Akil Mutawakkil.
CurrentlyAI Product Designer & Manager @ ChatDaddy
Based inBondowoso, Indonesia
All projects
Case study · Traveloka · 2022

Making ‘Pay at Hotel’ transparent

Pay at the hotel is one of several payments when booking a hotel.

Remotemoderated usability testing
Success ratethe metric used to measure each task
3screens redesigned: room, card check, summary
2022Traveloka, Pay at Hotel
Traveloka Credit Card Payment cover
01

The story

Overview

Pay at the hotel is one of several payments when booking a hotel. Pay at the hotel is charged at the hotel upon check-in or check-out, at the discretion of the hotel. A credit card is required to reserve the room through platform but will not be charged prior to your stay at the hotel. A physical credit card must also be provided upon check-in for the cost of the room and incidentals. Tripaction.com

Pay at Hotel is all about payment flexibility! Guests are able to secure a booking without an advance payment. Instead, guests will pay the full amount during their stay at the property, either by cash or by card.

To book, guests will need to provide their credit card details which will be used only to guarantee the booking, so it will not be charged at the time of booking. Traveloka.com

Traveloka is one of the platforms that implement this kind of service. but various problems are faced by users when they use pay at hotels using a credit card. such as unspecified errors while checking credit card information, unsynchronized conditions on the payment page and booking list page, a confirmation page missing, and one step missing in the process.

A feature that indicates success is if it meets user needs by carrying full functions, reliability, usefulness, and ease of use. To meet better experience in payment transactions it should be secure, trustworthy, and transparent. To identify those user problems, usability testing is a suited method to evaluate a product or service by testing it with representative users. During a test, participants will be asked to complete specific tasks while one or more observers watch, listen, and record notes. The main goal of this user experience testing method is to identify usability problems, collect qualitative data, and determine participants’ overall satisfaction with the product.

About Traveloka

Traveloka is Southeast Asia’s travel and lifestyle app, that provides access to discover and purchase different types of travel needs, local services, and financial services products. Traveloka’s comprehensive product portfolio includes transport booking services such as flight tickets, buses, trains, car rentals, and airport transfers, as well as access to the largest accommodation inventory in Southeast Asia.

Goals & Objectives

Solutions:

The goals of usability testing usually include:

Identifying problems in the design of the product or serviceUncovering opportunities to improveLearning about the target user’s behavior and preferences
Traveloka Credit Card Payment

Usability Matrics: Success Rate

A very simple binary metric in user experience is task success or completion. running a test with multiple users and reporting the success and task completion rate. by that matrics, we know why users fail or how well they perform the task they did complete

Traveloka Credit Card Payment

Methodology: Remote Testing

Remote Testing is similar to in-person studies. The facilitator still interacts with the participant and asks them to perform tasks. However, the facilitator and participant are in different physical locations. Usually, moderated tests can be performed using screen-sharing software like google meet, zoom, etc.

02

Key moments

Key moment helps understand every steps that require to reach the goal

Traveloka Credit Card Payment

Collect feedback/insight/pain points from Business, Researcher, Engineers, and user

Traveloka Credit Card Payment

Understand

understanding user feedback/insight/pain points from business, reasearch, engineers and user

Traveloka Credit Card Payment

Define

select which issues that can solve most user need in prior time with reasonable effort

Traveloka Credit Card Payment

Converge

Take away solution for business, engineers, and design to solve user pain point based on key moments

03

Room eligibility

Traveloka Credit Card Payment
04

Card confirmation

to keep transparency during checking and verifying credit card information, tell user WHATS GOING ON on the screen

Traveloka Credit Card Payment

To secure safety verification on user side, put verified status checking credit card to show the name on the card after checking the card, after they confirm the card, user can proceed the card for guarantee.

Traveloka Credit Card Payment
05

Booking summary

based on the most issues faced by users, it is very important for them to see the booking summary page

Traveloka Credit Card Payment
06

What I learned

Pay at hotel gives flexibility to user not to pay at the moment, the credit card is given only to guarantee if user did not attend at hotel, it will charge in the period of time as written. As conducting usability testing on this feature they seem easy to do the task until credit card input. After they correct the error input, error notification appear very general, user didn’t know where the error exactly is,

Traveloka Credit Card Payment

when I ask what will they do in that condition, they assumed many things, either the card cannot be used, the hotel not receive pay at hotel and the platform system were broken. The platform did not transparent about the process. If the payment page the card having trouble checking but yet in the order list page, They are checking the card without us not knowing it and not under user’s subconscious.

The reason for having this usability testing was coming from my personal experience, and I want to test several user so I am not the only one having this kind of issue

One by one issue that they face in usability testing were also faced by me in real life, scenario that they tell me also I did in real life when I use this feature

The screen they share is exactly the same as I experience in real life

How if user did not aware of the anonymous check on the background and they assuming the card cannot proceed and choose another hotel and end up in the same condition

They are very concerned about this issue because this is about user money. It's very sensitive and risky part

Got questions?

Let's build products
that actually think.

I’m always excited to collaborate on innovative and exciting projects.

Phone+62 852 2845 4057